Is Floyd Mayweather underrated?


Floyd Mayweather listens at a press conference ahead of his upcoming fight with Andre Berto. (Getty)

LAS VEGAS – It’s difficult to wrap one’s arms around the idea that an athlete who is audacious enough to refer to himself as “The Best Ever,” in his sport may actually be underappreciated.
But when it comes to Floyd Mayweather, that may be the case.
One of the least-appreciated facts of Mayweather’s marvelous career, which comes to a conclusion on Saturday against Andre Berto at the MGM Grand Garden, is that more than half of his professional opponents were or had been world champions at the time he fought them.
Berto, who is a former welterweight title-holder, will become the 16th consecutive current or former champion Mayweather will have met, and the 24th in what will be his 49th fight.

That is a remarkable accomplishment, even if not all of those fighters were at their peak at the time Mayweather fought them.

His bout against Berto will be his 26th world championship bout (he fought Marcos Maidana and Jose Luis Castillo twice each), meaning 53 percent of all his bouts were for a major world title (either the WBC, WBA, WBO or IBF world belts).
He’s held championships in five weight classes, at super featherweight, lightweight, super lightweight, welterweight and super welterweight.
He was 9-0 in 130-pound championship matches. He was 4-0 in lightweight title fights, 1-0 in super lightweight title matches, 8-0 in welterweight championship bouts and 3-0 in super welterweight championship bouts.

The following is a more in-depth look at Mayweather’s title fight success division by division:
Super featherweight, 9-0, 6 KOs – Mayweather was 17-0 when he challenged the highly regarded Genaro Hernandez for his first world title on Oct. 3, 1998, eight days shy of two years from the day he turned professional. This is the class where he had some of his most impressive performances.
In 2001, he knocked Diego Corrales down five times and stopped him in the 10th round in a battle of unbeaten champions. He also scored a ninth-round stoppage of the underrated Jesus Chavez in a card on which his future rival, Manny Pacquiao, fought on the undercard.
Lightweight, 4-0, 1 KO – Mayweather began to run into critics when he made the move to lightweight in 2002 to face Jose Luis Castillo. At the time, Castillo was widely regarded as the best lightweight in the world.
Mayweather won that April 20, 2002, bout at the MGM by unanimous decision, though not without much controversy. Judges scored it for Mayweather by a wide margin, giving him a win by scores of 115-111, 116-111 and 115-111.
But Castillo threw more punches (506-448), landed more (203-157) and connected at a higher percentage (40-35) according to CompuBox statistics. That prompted HBO’s Harold Lederman to score the bout in favor of Castillo, as did many of HBO’s viewers.
Top Rank’s Bob Arum, who was then promoting Mayweather, said after the fight he felt Mayweather won, but disagreed with the margin. Later, Arum would say he felt Castillo had been jobbed.
Mayweather, who said he injured his shoulder on the last day of training for the fight, gave Castillo a rematch in December. He won that fight more convincingly.
It was the highlight of his lightweight reign. He’d go on to defeat non-descript opponents, Victoriano Sosa and Philip N’Dou, before moving to super lightweight.
Super lightweight, 1-0, 1 KO – Mayweather made his pay-per-view debut in his only title fight at 140 pounds, and it was an easy one-sided victory over Arturo Gatti.
Floyd Mayweather rips Arturo Gatti with a body shot during their 2005 fight. (Getty) 

The fight was never in doubt, as Mayweather’s hands were too fast for Gatti, who could never catch Mayweather. He won all six rounds until Gatti trainer Buddy McGirt stopped the bout.
There were great opponents for him at 140, notably Kostya Tszyu, but Mayweather abandoned the division in favor of welterweight without ever defending his title.
Welterweight, 8-0, 2 KOs – Mayweather is most closely associated with the 147-pound weight class, where many of the sport’s greatest stars, including Sugar Ray Robinson, Sugar Ray Leonard, Thomas Hearns and Oscar De La Hoya competed.
Mayweather’s welterweight title opponents had a combined record of 268-27-11, a winning percentage of 89.4 at the time he met them. This doesn’t include non-title fights in that span in which he beat Juan Manuel Marquez, who was 50-4-1 at the time, or Shane Mosley, who was 46-5.
He debuted in a non-title fight against ex-champion Sharmba Mitchell, and looked sharp in scoring a sixth-round knockout.
After a slow start, he figured out Zab Judah and was highly impressive, perhaps the most impressive performance of his welterweight title run.
He defeated Pacquiao in the largest-grossing fight of all time, but it was a largely ho-hum fight and came long after both had passed their primes.
Mayweather bounced back and forth during this span between welterweight and super welterweight and didn’t look as good at 147 as he did at 154.
Super welterweight, 3-0, 0 KOs – Three of his four best pay-per-views came at super welterweight, as he defeated Oscar De La Hoya, Miguel Cotto and Canelo Alvarez. The three bouts combined to sell 6.3 million on pay-per-view and helped establish him as the No. 1 gate attraction in the sport.
He routed both Cotto and Alvarez, but took a split decision over an aging De La Hoya. De La Hoya tired midway through the fight and let Mayweather take over rolling down the stretch.
Summary of his career – In baseball, Hall of Fame players who have been with multiple teams have to choose which team’s cap they want to display on their plaques.
If Mayweather had to make that choice, super featherweight would probably be the way he should go. He was as brilliant as ever defensively, but was a far more effective offensive fighter.
He threw more and hit harder in his early days.
Does Andre Berto (R) stand a chance against undefeated Floyd Mayweather? (Reuters)
As he moved up in weight, he was more economical with his punches and didn’t carry the same kind of snap on his shots that he did earlier in his career.
It’s been a masterful career, though not without plenty of criticism. Critics wanted to see him fight foes like De La Hoya, Mosley, Cotto and Pacquiao earlier.
He wanted De La Hoya early on in his career, but De La Hoya was the sport’s biggest draw at the time and made Mayweather wait.
There are fierce arguments among boxing experts as to why he didn’t fight opponents such as Mosley, Cotto, Pacquiao and others earlier.
Regardless, though, there are few legitimate opponents during his nearly two decades as a pro who were available for him to fight that he didn’t fight.
He’d be remembered more kindly by boxing historians if he’d fought some of them earlier, most notably Pacquiao, as well as more aggressively.
But when it came to what ultimately matters – winning – he had whatever it took each time out.





Previous Post Next Post